The Land O'Lakes Blog

— Bringing inspiration to those who share our love of good food. —
Sparkling Candy Corn Cookies

Sparkling Candy Corn Cookies

Candy Corn is a “must have” around Halloween time.  These tasty morsels are addictive.  I don’t know about you, but I just couldn’t imagine not having at least one handful  sometime during the month of October. 

Halloween also is a very fun day for kids.  They dress up in costumes and get more candy then they normally see in an entire year.  When my boys were young they planned their costumes weeks ahead of October 31.   Their requests soon were way out of my league to create so they would make the yearly phone call to my sister, a master seamstress, and make their costume request.  Being a doting aunt, she always came through and delivered the exact costume requested. There was Tweety Bird, George Washington, Robin Hood, Darth Vader, a fireman and Percy the Train, just to name a few.  Now that my boys are beyond the trick or treating years we gather for a Halloween supper and then have fun giving out treats to the neighborhood kids.  I like to have something a little special for our supper that night and this year I’ve decided to make these very cute cookies.

Sparkling Candy Corn Cookies  marry the seasonal favorite, candy corn, with all the fun Halloween brings.  They may look a little complicated to make but, are really quite easy.  This is the perfect recipe for step-by-step photos because the photos will make it clear just how simple these cookies are to make.  I have never heard so many “those are so cute” and “what a great idea” comments with any recipe as I heard about this one.  They are great for Halloween parties, any fall gathering or for tucking in the lunch box as a special treat.  So, have some fun and give these treats a try.

The first step is to line the bottom and sides of a 9x5-inch loaf pan with waxed paper or plastic food wrap.  Then set the prepared pan aside.

loafpanwaxpaper-copy

Now to make the cookie dough beat together the butter and sugar until creamy.

untilcreamy2-copy1

Add the egg, orange juice, orange peel and salt.  Continue beating until well mixed.

addeggojpeelsalt1-copy

Reduce the mixer speed to low and add the flour and baking soda.  Again, beat until well mixed.

addfloursoda1-copy

Once the dough is prepared it’s time to add the food coloring.  First divide the dough into three equal parts.  Be sure to wash your hands and then press one of the thirds into the bottom of the pan lined with waxed paper.

pressinwhitedough-copy

Press the dough evenly to cover the entire bottom of the pan.

whitedoughbottom1-copy

For the second layer, place another one of the thirds of dough into a bowl.  Add a small amount of orange food color and mix until well blended and evenly colored.  If you don’t have orange food color you can always use a combination of red and yellow to create orange.

addorangefoodcolo1r-copy

It’s best to start with less food color and add more to make the color more intense, if needed.  The color should be fairly strong (just think “candy corn” and strive to reach that orange color.)

addorangefoodcolor2-copy

Now press the orange dough evenly over the white dough already in the pan.

pressoranginpan-copy

Place the remaining one-third of dough in another bowl and add a small amount of yellow food color.  Mix until well blended.  The yellow should also be a fairly intense color.

colordoughyellow1-copy

Press the yellow dough on top of the orange dough in the pan.

pressyellowonorange-copy

Make sure it covers the orange dough in an even layer.  Cover with plastic food wrap and refrigerate until firm (at least two hours).  This is an easy recipe to make in two steps because the dough will be fine stored refrigerated.  So, you can make the dough and stop at this point.  Then you can slice and bake them a day or two later.  I recommend baking the cookies within two days of making the dough since the recipe contains an egg.

plasticwrap1-copy

When you are ready to bake the cookies, heat the oven to 375°F.  Place ½ cup of sugar in a large bowl. 

sugarinlargebowl-copy

On a cleaning cutting surface, invert the loaf pan to remove the dough.

invert1-copy

Remove the pan.

invert2-copy

Remove the waxed paper.  Just look at those beautiful layers!

removewaxpaper2-copy

Using a sharp knife, cut the dough “loaf” crosswise into ¼-inch slices.  Trim the edges to make slices even, if necessary.  If you are a perfectionist you will want to trim, if you are okay with some “deformed” candy corn cookies, don’t bother.

cutquarterinchslices-copy

Cut each slice into 6 wedges.  Again, you perfectionists out there may want to do some trimming.  Now you can see the “candy corn.”

cutintotriangles-copy

Place the cookies 1-inch apart on ungreased cookie sheets.

oncookiesheet1-copy

Bake for 7 to 10 minutes or until the edges are firm and the bottoms are very lightly browned.

lightbrown1-copy

Cool 1 minute.  Remove the cookies from the cookie sheet and immediately place the warm cookies in the bowl of sugar.

placewarmcookiesinsugar-copy

Roll the cookies in the sugar to coat.

rollinsugar1-copy

Place the sugar-coated cookies on a cooling rack and let them cool completely.

rollinsugar3-copy

I store them in a loosely covered container so the sugar coating stays nice and doesn't "melt" from the moisture in a tightly closed container.

See, I told you these were easy to make with the help of pictures.  These cookies make me smile.  They are just so adorable and they have a wonderful buttery flavor with just the right hint of orange.  Now that I know what treat I’m going to make I can start concentrating on my costume.  I guess I better call my sister!

Let me know if you have any tips that might help others when they make these cookies.  And please, don’t forget to rate and review the Sparkling Candy Corn Cookies recipe.

Check back in a few days when Alex will share another Halloween recipe, perfect for getting your kids involved in the kitchen.

Becky Wahlund is the Director of the Test Kitchens for Land O'Lakes and writes for our Recipe Buzz® Blog.

Back to Top

Leave a Comment

Please note, all submissions are screened for content deemed appropriate by Land O'Lakes. Comments are published within 3 business days.

Comments

I want to make these but don't have any orange juice. Any ideas on substitutiions?

Posted October 30, 2015 by kathy
Test Kitchen Comment
From: mallory
Hi Kathy, you could substitute any type of juice, it just won't have the orange flavor. If you don't have any juice on hand, milk would work, as well. Happy baking!
Posted November 04, 2015

Do these need to be stored in refridg? I want to send them to my son in college for Halloween. Thanks.

Posted October 02, 2013 by robin
Test Kitchen Comment
From: Cindy
No, these cookies do not need to be stored in the refrigerator. They are a crisper type cookie and so are best stored at room temp. in a loosely covered container.
Posted October 04, 2013

They turned out great but no way does this recipe make 15 dozen cookies. We got about half that amount.

Posted September 03, 2013 by Chris

Love this idea! Just wanted to say that your pin link is incorrect, it points to a page that doesn't exist. :-)

Posted October 21, 2012 by Kim
Test Kitchen Comment
From: Cindy
Thanks for alerting us that the pin link did not work. Now it does work. There was a change in code that was the issue. Thanks again!
Posted October 29, 2012

where is the ingredients list with the amounts? It wasn't in the recipe.

Posted October 19, 2012 by Darla
Test Kitchen Comment
From: Cindy
Darla, Just click on the underlined name of the cookie in the blog. That link will take you to the recipe where you will find ingredient amounts and the actual recipe method.
Posted October 20, 2012

This is one of the best cookie recipes I have ever done

Posted October 15, 2012 by Marie Chizek

These were so tasty! I made double batch; one regular and one with the "chocolate". Both were delicious. I ended up making the dough on Sunday and not actually getting to bake them until 4 days later. Brought some to work and they were gone within minutes.

Posted October 12, 2012 by Terri
Test Kitchen Comment
From: Cindy
Excellent! They are a fun cookie to share in this season! It is fun to hear your story!
Posted October 15, 2012

These look so cute and easy. But what are the measurements for all the ingredients.

Posted September 25, 2012 by abby
Test Kitchen Comment
From: Cindy
The name of the recipe is underlined in both the beginning and near the end of the blog. If you click on that underlined recipe name it will link you to the actual recipe with the ingredient amounts and method. Hope you have fun making these cookies!
Posted September 27, 2012

Paula, Yes, you can use liquid food coloring when making this cookie recipe. You will need to take care when using the coloring and add it slowly. It may take a little more coloring than if you use gel or paste color to get a darker color since it is not as concentrated a color.

Posted October 29, 2010 by Cindy