One of Our Most Requested Recipes - Butter Toffee Cookies

Once in awhile we come up with a recipe that is an all around winner. It’s made from simple ingredients, it’s easy to make and everyone loves it. Butter Toffee Cookies is one of those recipes. As a matter of fact, it has become one of our most requested recipes.

SEE THE RECIPE

beauty shot

Once in awhile we come up with a recipe that is an all around winner. It’s made from simple ingredients, it’s easy to make and everyone loves it. Butter Toffee Cookies is one of those recipes. As a matter of fact, it has become one of our most requested recipes.

Now, Butter Toffee Cookies are not a fancy cookie; it’s not something to make when you are trying to impress your friends or family. But, if you want a recipe that you know will be enjoyed and disappear from the cookie plate quick as can be, then this is the recipe to make.

The only “special” ingredient you will need to pick up at the grocery store is an 8 ounce bag of toffee bits or milk chocolate toffee bits. You’ll find this “secret ingredient” in the baking section of your store near the chocolate chips and nuts. I consider the toffee bits to be the secret ingredient because they add just the right touch of sweetness, crunch and flavor to a butter cookie base. Below is a picture of the two types of toffee bits. On the left are the toffee bits and on the right are the milk chocolate toffee bits.

1c Toffee and chocolate toffee bits

I will admit that I love toffee, as did my father-in-law, Don. No meal was complete for Don without a cup of coffee and a little something sweet. These cookies were just the right thing to satisfy his craving and provide a proper ending to a meal. Of course, he thought they made a great snack just about any time of day.

Heat the oven to 350°F. Combine the sugar, butter, egg and vanilla in a large bowl.

1 Combine Butter Egg Sugar Vanilla 1

Beat at medium speed, scraping the bowl often, until the mixture is creamy.

2 Beat Until Creamy 4

Add the flour, baking powder and baking soda.

3 Add Flour 2

Reduce the mixer speed to low so you don’t throw flour all over everything and beat the dough until well mixed. The dough will start to form a ball of sorts.

4 Beat Until Well Mixed 1

Now, add the toffee bits.

5 Add Toffee Bits 2

And stir them in by hand.

5 Stir in bits 4

Shape the dough into 1-inch balls.

6 one in balls 1

Roll the balls of dough in sugar to evenly coat.

7 roll in sugar 2

Place sugar coated balls 2 inches apart onto ungreased cookie sheet.

8 Place 2 in apart 1

Flatten balls with the bottom of a glass to form1 ½-inch circles. If the glass sticks to the cookie dough just lightly grease the bottom of the glass with a little butter and dip it into sugar, and then flatten the balls.

9a Flatten with Glass 2

For another look you can flatten the balls with a fork in a criss-cross pattern (similar to making old-fashioned peanut butter cookies).

9b Flatten with Fork 3

Bake for 9 to 11 minutes or until the edges are just lightly browned. It’s important to not over bake the cookies because they will not have a nice chewy texture and the toffee bits may begin to burn.

10 Edges Brown 1

Sprinkle with sugar while still warm to give them a “sparkling” appearance.

11 Sprinkle with Sugar 2

Cool completely. Here is a photo of what the cookies will look like when you flatten the balls with a fork (on the left) versus a glass (on the right).

9a Difference Between Fork and Glass 1

Butter Toffee Cookies are a long time favorite here are Land O’Lakes. I think they might become one of your favorites too, especially if you need “just a little something sweet” to satisfy your carving.

12 Final Shot 2

Once you try them, please leave me a comment and I’d love it if you took a minute to rate and review Butter Toffee Cookies too.

Up next, a great brunch recipe.

Becky Wahlund is the Director of the Test Kitchens for Land O'Lakes and writes for our Recipe Buzz™ Blog.

Ready to make the recipe? Let’s get started making Butter Toffee Cookies!

Butter Toffee Cookies Image
Butter Toffee Cookies